Many ask about Thanksgiving in Key West and wonder where they can get a traditional Thanksgiving dinner. Others ask, which restaurants are open in Key West on Thanksgiving day?
This guide will share where you can enjoy a Thanksgiving meal in Key West in 2024.
If you are not looking for a festive holiday meal, you are still in luck because most Key West restaurants will be open and waiting to serve you on Thanksgiving, whether you find yourself on or off Duval Street. You’ll find seafood, steaks, chicken, burgers, perhaps a happy hour, and more if you are not in the mood for turkey.
In the Florida Keys, we have many reasons to be thankful. There is gorgeous weather, abundant water activities, incredible local tastes and cuisine, and a casual way of living. Many choose to visit because of that, and some may stay over for the Thanksgiving holiday.
When is Thanksgiving in Key West?
In the US, Thanksgiving is celebrated on the fourth Thursday in November. This year, it will be on November 28th, 2024, all around the country and in Key West.
Is Thanksgiving a Good Time to Go to or Visit Key West?
Absolutely yes! Hurricane season is nearing its end. The days are warm with plenty of sunshine. Tourism continues in Key West and the Florida Keys in November and over Thanksgiving. Many restaurants celebrate Thanksgiving Day, and there are countless other activities.
How About Key West Thanksgiving Weather?
Chances are better than not that if you are in Key West for Thanksgiving, the weather will be sunny with a chance of cocktails. Finding no fault in that forecast, you should come to Key West and enjoy some of our Thanksgiving weather. Also, we can guarantee there will not be any snow!
Thanksgiving in Key West: Where to Eat, Who is Open
Below is a rundown of the Key West restaurants that will be open and offering Thanksgiving day options for 2024. You’ll see turkey lunch, dinner, catering, takeaway choices, and regular menus.
If you come to Key West during Thanksgiving, you will have nothing to worry about food-wise.
This page is continuously updated as information comes in. Bookmark it and check back often for the latest Key West Thanksgiving happenings.
Brady’s Pub Key West
Thanksgiving is right around the corner, and at Brady’s, you can watch the games and have a traditional turkey meal with all the trimmings in one spot!
Come for some turkey and good times on Thanksgiving day.
They have been practicing with Turkey Tuesday specials every Tuesday to get that turkey meal just right. Plenty of cold draughts will get you through; even some delicious pies are on the dessert offerings.
Located at: 1900 Flagler Ave, Key West, FL 33040 • (305) 295-8880
Broil
This fabulous steakhouse on Cudjoe Key is always running a special and is no different for Thanksgiving.
Broil is already taking reservations for their Thanksgiving Brunch Buffet, which will be held from 11 to 2 pm and is $75 per person.
Please contact Lola (573) 220-8812 to claim your spot.
Located at: 21611 Old State Rd 4a, Cudjoe Key, Florida 33042 • (305) 741-7879
Cafe Sole
The good folks at Cafe Sole told me, “Every year, we make a full New England-style Thanksgiving dinner.”
This year, it will feature… Chef’s Traditional Holiday Meal
- Marinated Turkey Roasted to perfection and accompanied by Smoked Oyster & Apple Stuffing.
- Gourmet Mashed Potatoes with our Homemade Three-Day Gravy.
- Fresh Cranberry Orange Compote, Green Beans in Bacon, Baked Apples, Candied Yams, Acorn Squash, a Medley of Roasted Root Vegetables, and Cream of Corn.
- Homemade sweet potato pie, pumpkin pie, french apple pie, or Key lime pie
So please call ahead or book on Open Table to make reservations.
Thanksgiving Holiday Menu and regular menu will be available.
Located at: 1029 Southard St, Key West, FL 33040 • (305) 294-0230
Dante’s Key West
Dante’s would like to invite you to their yearly showstopping All You Can Eat Thanksgiving Buffet!
There is no need to worry about the cooking and cleaning…leave that to them! Your only worries are how much you can fit on your plate and what to drink.
Besides, how often do you get to enjoy Thanksgiving poolside soaking up the sun & fresh air?
There are no reservations, and all tables and seating are first come, first served! So head on over to Dante’s for a day of good food, good drinks, good laughs, and good times.
Located at: 955 Caroline St, Key West, FL 33040 • (305) 293-5123
Destination Catering & Events
Get your Thanksgiving Dinner ready for pick up with this fantastic holiday offer from Destination Catering & Events: $170. This cost includes everything you need for up to four people to dig into a delightful Thanksgiving Feast with selections from the following menu options.
- Pick two proteins – Traditional Herb Roasted Turkey, Jerk Pork Roast, or Jerk Turkey.
- Choose one salad – Grilled Watermelon or Key Lime Caesar
- All sides are included – Cornbread Stuffing, Garlic Cream Potatoes, Bacon Sweet Chili Green Beans, Cranberry Sauce, Lobster Mac & Cheese, and Jamaican Coconut Rice & Beans
- Chef’s selection of mini desserts, three pieces per person, and may include – Apple Pie Verrine, Pecan Bar, Coffee Cheesecake, Carrot Spice Cake, Pumpkin Cheesecake, Salted Caramel Bar, Pumpkin Mousse, Keylime Tartlet
Order online by Monday, November 18th (link provided above) or call for further information.
Located at: 111 Overseas Hwy Suite #102, Key West, FL 33040 • (305) 517-6513
Duffy’s Steak & Lobster House
Duffy’s will serve its regular menu and Traditional Thanksgiving options this year. It is a popular spot, and many look forward to dining there.
Will you opt for the Prime Rib, New York Strip, or perhaps a Surf & Turf? All of those will be available on the regular menu, in addition to the Thanksgiving options.
Call to make reservations for anyone, especially for larger groups.
Located at: 1007 Simonton St, Key West, FL 33040 • (305) 296-4900
Four Flamingos – Richard Blais Key West Kitchen(at the Hyatt Centric)
I discovered the Thanksgiving menu on their website.
$90 per person, including a chip appetizer, a choice from two salads or soup, a traditional turkey main course (jerk brined this year), and choose from two desserts.
Thanksgiving dinner will offer a signature Holiday Prix Fixe menu with a Key West twist.
An add-on seafood platter option will be available. Dinner will be served from 2 pm to 9 pm.
The seafood option features a Key West pink shrimp cocktail, octopus salsa, smoked fish dip tostada, and oysters for $45.
You can click here to reserve your spot for Thanksgiving now.
Located at: 601 Front St, Key West, FL 33040 • (305) 809-4000
Four Marlins Oceanfront Dining (at The Reach)
Enjoy a traditional Thanksgiving dinner with all your favorite dishes on Thursday, November 28th, from 5:30 p.m. to 9:30 p.m. Live music will be on the patio from 5:00 p.m. to 9:00 p.m.
Call the number below to reserve or book on Open Table.
For $95, you can get a Thanksgiving dinner for two to go, including an oven-roasted turkey breast with gravy and cranberry orange chutney, four sides, two portions of honey-jalapeno glaze cheddar biscuits, and two slices of pie.
Call 305-293-6250 to order by 5 p.m. Tuesday, November 26th. Pickup will be available on Thanksgiving day from 11 a.m. to 4 p.m.
Leftover Brunch at Four Marlins is on Saturday and Sunday, Nov 30th – Dec 1st, with bottomless mimosas, ala carte choices, and desserts.
From 7:00 am – 2:00 pm with live music from 10:00 am – 2:00 pm.
Located at: 1435 Simonton St, Key West, FL 33040 • (305) 293-6250
Fury Key West Thanksgiving Ultimate Adventure H2.O
Enjoy a day on the water with fun activities and a turkey lunch. It doesn’t get more Florida or Key West than that. The following is from Fury’s website and a link to take you to this event.
It departs from the corner of Greene St. and Elizabeth St. next to The Conch Republic Seafood Company. • (855) 831-5997 toll-free
Grand Cafe
Traditional Thanksgiving and their fabulous regular menu will be served at the Grand Cafe from noon until 9 pm.
- Baked Carved Turkey Breast with Gravy
- Seasonal Herbed Stuffing with Thyme and Shallots
- Cranberry Relish
- Potato Puree
- Creamed Spinach
- Pricing to be announced
Call Grand Cafe to make your reservations.
Located at: 314 Duval St, Key West, FL 33040 • (305) 292-4740
Great Events Catering
For Thanksgiving this year, if you do not want to worry about who has to cook, let Great Events Catering take care of everything.
They have a Thanksgiving feast available that you can pick up for your traditional holiday meal.
The cost is $160 for a dinner for four. Pickup is between 10 and 3 on Thanksgiving Day.
Order by Monday, November 25th.
Located at: 925 Truman Ave, Key West, FL 33040 • (305) 294-2252
Hot Tin Roof
Browsing Hot Tin Roof’s website, I discovered their Thanksgiving offering: $130 per person for those who enjoy dining at their prime location.
Enjoy a delicious four-course menu of seasonal selections.
No menu is present yet. Last year, there was plenty of delectable variety to choose from.
Reservations are required. Call to book your table today.
Located at: 0 Duval St, Key West, FL 33040 • (305) 295-7057
La Te Da
On upper Duval Steet, La Te Da gets into the swing of things every year with a traditional turkey meal with all the fixings.
Call to secure your reservations early, as this one does fill up quickly!
The picture at the top of this post is from a Thanksgiving meal at La Te Da a few years ago.
They will offer a traditional Thanksgiving menu: roasted turkey, sausage stuffing, giblet gravy, cranberry sauce, mashed potatoes, green beans with almonds, pineapple casserole, and candied yams with marshmallows.
La Te Da will have Pumpkin or Pecan Pie with homemade whipped cream for Thanksgiving dessert.
Served from 2–8 pm, reservations are required—pricing to be announced.
Come and see why many recommend La Te Da as one of the best places to have Thanksgiving dinner in Key West.
Located at: 1125 Duval St, Key West, FL 33040 • (305) 296-6706
Milagro Restaraunt & Bar
Two blocks from the Southernmost Point, you’ll find Milagro. From 2 to 8:30 pm, they will have a memorable holiday menu featuring Thanksgiving flavors with a Milagro twist.
You will also be able to access the full menu, which is amazing and full of excellent dining choices.
Milagro will offer Thanksgiving ala carte choices for the big day, featuring two starters, two entrees, and a sweet dessert.
Located at: 1401 Simonton St, Key West, FL 33040 • (305) 440-3534
One Duval
One Duval within the Pier House offers Thanksgiving specials for dining patrons. Enjoy their Thanksgiving specials and regular menus with lovely ocean views all day.
This year, their Thanksgiving menu will feature…
- Starters: Lobster Bisque or a Roasted Beet & Goat Cheese Salad.
- Main Course: Choose from freshly caught Stone Crabs (1lb or 1/2 lb options), a classic Traditional Turkey Dinner, or Herb-Crusted Prime Rib.
- Dessert: Pumpkin Pie or Bourbon Pecan Pie.
The Thanksgiving menu can be found on the link provided above.
Located at: 1 Duval St, Key West, FL 33040 • (305) 295-325
Pepe’s Cafe & Steakhouse
If you are feeling hungry and somewhat festive on any Thursday, stop by Pepe’s Cafe for a traditional turkey feast around dinner time.
Thanksgiving dinner is available every Thursday throughout the year. If you happen to be there earlier in the day, say at lunchtime, you’ll find a Thanksgiving sandwich on Pepe’s lunch menu.
Pepe’s will begin its traditional Thanksgiving holiday dinner at 1 p.m. The Key West Thanksgiving Day menu includes light and dark turkey, stuffing, gravy, mashed potatoes, cranberry sauce, and peas.
Located at: 806 Caroline St, Key West, FL 33040 • (305) 294-7192
We Wish You a Happy and Safe Thanksgiving, Whether in Key West or Elsewhere
As you can see, many options exist for discovering the best place to have Thanksgiving dinner in Key West. Don’t forget that you can also locate Thanksgiving lunch, a Thanksgiving sunset dinner cruise, and order from most regular menus.
Many Key West restaurants remain open on Thanksgiving, and for that, we are thankful.
Please share this with your friends or with your groups for those who may be interested in all of the Thanksgiving options in Key West.
This was a really great and helpful article. Thanks!